Score: 8

"There was a lot of good music..."

submission: wingly city -time of arrogance

date: May 27, 2008

In LoD... I wish they did more with that lore...

I think originally this song was much more foreboding and dark. Lots of the music was that way, but this one in particular seemed to resonate the thousands of years Rose spent killing the Moonchild. This version is a bit less dark, but I like it.

Score: 8

"God I loved that game..."

submission: EWJ - Queen Slug for a Butt

date: May 27, 2008

Shiny Entertainment could have made this generation of games much more interesting...

As for the song, I don't remember exactly how it went in the game, but this is a catchy incarnation. I think this was the final boss theme, but you kinda made it sound like an 'exploring a cave' song... at least... a cave in the EWJ universe o.O

Score: 9

"I have the other version..."

submission: *+(Sonata of True Darkness)+*

date: May 27, 2008

I like it with the ambiance better, personally. This is essentially just the instrumental part of the song which is nice, but doesn't have the same impact nor tell quite the same story as with the ambiance.

Sometimes I wish i could play piano so I could recreate this king of stuff.

Score: 9

"Wel done, but the end cuts off..."

submission: -*Eternity*-

date: May 27, 2008

You're missing like 2 bars of music from the tail end of the song, otherwise a good rendition of the song done in a different style.

Score: 9

"Haunting Adaptation"

submission: *+*+(Star Stealing Girl)+*+*

date: September 4, 2006

Originally this melody had a more angelic, choir quality in the source material. You've successfully transformed it into a hopeful dirge of sorts.

In WoW I've recently started using an add-on that changes the area music for different places. I used this song for Chillwind Camp, one of the last basions of hope in the Plaguelands.

It's an excellent piece, well done!

Score: 9

"I like the description."

submission: *+*+(Symphony of Darkness)+*+*

date: May 22, 2006

After hearing the straight piano version of this, I'm glad you went back over it and did some more arranging with sounds (especially the giggling). The desription you gave - about the little girl chasing her shadow - evoked a series of images that went with the music.

A very nice story piece in the end. It has a beginning, a middle and an end - even being only 2:18.

Probably the best original you've made.

Score: 8

"Very catchy"

submission: +*+*(Heavens Above-DEMO-)*+*+

date: April 22, 2006

It works nicely as a loop. It's almost inspiring me to create a flash around it...

I think I'll wait for the finished song, though.

Score: 8

"It's very good, but..."

submission: +*+*(+)Moonlight Shadow(+)*+*+

date: April 18, 2006

The whole second half of the lyrics is missing. I looked up the lyrics online, then found 8 versions of the song through media player. It's still good, but it probably could have been better with all the lyrics.

I have it on my playlist anyway...